St. Thomas taxis usually charge by destination and per person, not by a meter. Here’s how the system works and what common cruise-day rides currently cost.
The first surprise about St.Thomas taxis is usually not the price.
It is how the price works .
If you are used to Uber or metered taxis, you may expect one fare for the vehicle.
St.Thomas commonly works differently.
Published taxi rates are generally per person, by destination .
That distinction matters a lot when six people step into the same van.
How St.Thomas Taxi Pricing Works
The territory uses established destination - based taxi rates.
There is typically:
one rate for a single passenger
and
a lower per - person rate for two or more people traveling together in the same group.
So a published "$12" fare may mean $12 per person , not $12 for everyone.
Confirm before leaving.
Havensight to Magens Bay
Current published rates list approximately:
1 passenger: $15
2 or more in the same group: $12 per person
That means a group of four would pay around $48 each way before gratuity, based on the current tariff.
Now you can see why the per - person detail matters.
Crown Bay to Magens Bay
Current published rates are approximately:
1 passenger: $18
2 or more: $15 per person
Again, that is per person.
Havensight to Red Hook
Expect roughly the mid - teens per person depending on the exact pickup / drop - off point and group size.
This is relevant if you are heading toward the St.John ferry.
Remember that Red Hook is on the opposite side of the island from the main cruise harbor.
Build the drive time into the plan too.
Magens Bay Back to Havensight
Current published rates list:
1 passenger: $15
2 or more: $12 per person
Do not assume the return ride is included in what you paid going there unless you specifically arranged round - trip transportation.
Magens Bay to Crown Bay
Current rates list:
1 passenger: $18
2 or more: $15 per person
What About Coki or Sapphire ?
Fares depend on your exact origin.
Both are on the East End side of the island, so they generally cost more from the western side than a short ride around Charlotte Amalie.
If the entire cruise day is built around one of these beaches, ask the dispatcher for the current per - person fare before boarding.
Why Are There So Many Safari - Style Vehicles ?
Large open - air taxis are common around cruise traffic because they can move groups efficiently.
You may be sharing the vehicle with other passengers.
That does not mean everyone is paying one shared fare.
Each party pays according to the applicable tariff.
Can You Hire a Private Taxi ?
Yes.
But exclusive use is a different arrangement from joining a shared taxi.
Ask for the price before departure.
For a larger family or group, private transportation can sometimes make more sense than multiplying a per - person shared fare, especially if you want several stops.
Do the math.
What About Uber and Lyft ?
Do not build your St.Thomas cruise day around opening a rideshare app at the pier.
The island's transportation system relies heavily on licensed taxis, safari taxis, private transportation and rental vehicles rather than the same Uber/Lyft model visitors use on the mainland.
Arrange the transportation that actually exists here.
Is Cash Better ?
Carry cash.
Even when a particular driver accepts another form of payment, cash keeps the transaction simple.
Bring smaller U.S.bills rather than expecting everyone to make change for $100.
Do You Tip ?
Yes.
Taxi drivers are service workers.
Tip based on the service, especially if the driver handles luggage, waits for your group or provides private transportation.
When Does Renting a Car Make More Sense ?
For two people going directly from the ship to one beach and back, probably not.
For four or five people planning multiple stops across the island, the arithmetic changes.
But cruise - day car rental also adds:
• pickup time
• paperwork
• left - side driving
• parking
• return time
• fuel
Saving $25 is not useful if you spend an hour returning a car while the ship is preparing to leave.
Cruise - Day Taxi Math
Imagine four adults traveling from Havensight to Magens Bay.
At a current group rate around $12 per person:
Outbound: about $48
Return: about $48
That's roughly $96 round trip before tip.
Now compare that with whatever private transfer, excursion or rental option you're considering.
That is the useful comparison.
Confirm the Fare
Taxi tariffs can change.
Before leaving the port, ask:
"How much per person to [destination] for our group?"
Get the number.
Then go.
There is no reason for the price to become a surprise at the other end.
Local Tip
When somebody says:
"The taxi is $15."
ask the missing question:
"Fifteen dollars for the taxi, or fifteen dollars each?"
On St.Thomas, those are very different afternoons.
---
Conditions, access, prices, schedules, and availability can change. Confirm time-sensitive details with the responsible operator or public authority before you travel.