Beaches · Christiansted Harbor
Protestant Cay Beach
Protestant Cay is the beach travelers can see from the Christiansted boardwalk without ever setting foot on it — a small private island a two-minute water taxi ride offshore, run in connection with Hotel on the Cay. Non-hotel guests pay a round-trip fare (commonly cited around $5) for the ferry, which departs frequently from near the King Christian Hotel. Reviews are candid that the beach itself is modest: reviewers repeatedly note it's rocky in spots, with only a few clear sand entry points, and several say the snorkeling on the west side and around the boat dock is better than the beach itself. What draws repeat visitors back isn't really the sand — it's the setting: full bar and food service, water sports rentals, and views back across the harbor to Christiansted's waterfront that several reviewers call the real payoff. Some visitors mention a beachside entertainer running hermit-crab races with amplified narration as a genuine annoyance rather than a charm, so it's worth knowing this is a livelier, more programmed beach experience than St. Croix's quieter north-shore options.
Protestant Cay, Christiansted Harbor, St. Croix
Does this beach fit the day you want?
Protestant Cay is the beach travelers can see from the Christiansted boardwalk without ever setting foot on it — a small private island a two-minute water taxi ride offshore, run in connection with Hotel on the Cay. Non-hotel guests pay a round-trip fare (commonly cited around $5) for the ferry, which departs frequently from near the King Christian Hotel. Reviews are candid that the beach itself is modest: reviewers repeatedly note it's rocky in spots, with only a few clear sand entry points, and several say the snorkeling on the west side and around the boat dock is better than the beach itself. What draws repeat visitors back isn't really the sand — it's the setting: full bar and food service, water sports rentals, and views back across the harbor to Christiansted's waterfront that several reviewers call the real payoff. Some visitors mention a beachside entertainer running hermit-crab races with amplified narration as a genuine annoyance rather than a charm, so it's worth knowing this is a livelier, more programmed beach experience than St. Croix's quieter north-shore options.
What Island Hype can confirm
- Access
- boat
- Snorkeling
- good
- Family friendly
- Yes
- Facilities
- Water sports, restaurant, bar
- What to know
- Harbor cay
Good fit if you want
- snorkeling as part of your beach day
- a beach marked family-friendly
- facilities for the day
Keep the decision
Save Protestant Cay Beach if you want to compare it against other places later. Saving means you're still deciding, not booking.
These comparisons use the beach details available here, not real-time water conditions. Confirm current access and conditions before you go.
Photos
Make the next decision easier
What to decide next
Plan how you will get there
Resolve the transport decision before treating a beach as a complete day plan.
Add a water activity only if it fits
Browse activity options after the beach choice is clear.
Compare a stay shortlist
Choose where to base yourself separately from a beach-day consideration.